Skip to content
Monday - Friday: 10:00 - 6:00 | Saturday: 9:00 - 3:00Phone: 765-653-1335 |myersmarket@gmail.com
FacebookEmail
Myers’ Market Logo
  • Pre-Order
  • Sandwiches
    • See the Menu
    • Order a Sandwich
  • About
  • Catering
  • Contact
  • Shop Online
    • Jam/Jelly
    • Sauce
    • Honey/Syrup
    • Seasoning
    • Pickles
    • Snack
    • Condiments
    • Misc
    • Gift card
    • Gift Box
    • Beverage
  • Cart
  • My Account

    Register
  • Sort by Popularity
    • Sort by Name
    • Sort by Price
    • Sort by Date
    • Sort by Popularity
    • Sort by Rating
  • Show 20 Products
    • Show 20 Products
    • Show 40 Products
    • Show 60 Products
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Shoup’s 8oz Seasoning

    $5.99
    Shoup’s 8oz Seasoning
    Use in place of salt and pepper. Sprinkle according to taste. Great on grilled meats! No preservatives or MSG
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    St. Elmo Steak House – Izzy’s Sauce for Steak

    $5.99
    St. Elmo Steak House – Izzy’s Sauce for Steak
     
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Meat Mitch Steer Season

    $5.99
    Meat Mitch Steer Season
    1st place beef- Memphis in May World Championship
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Harris Sugar Bush Pint Harris Maple Syrup

    $8.50
    Harris Sugar Bush Pint Harris Maple Syrup
    Maple syrup from trees that are tapped here in Putnam Co. pure Indiana maple syrup.
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Hoosier Sugar Daddy Sassafras Syrup

    $10.00
    Hoosier Sugar Daddy Sassafras Syrup
    All natural, no preservative. Great for breakfast or an additive to drinks.
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Eisele’s Pure Honey 16oz Jar

    $9.99
    Eisele’s Pure Honey 16oz Jar
    All natural pure honey 16oz glass jar
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Shipshewana Gourmet Garlic Seasoning

    $6.99
    Shipshewana Gourmet Garlic Seasoning
    We are pleased to offer authentic Shipshewana Spice Co. Happy Salt with shipping anywhere in the US! Use as you would salt. Shake on meats, salads, vegetables, bread and more. Enjoy free shipping when you order a full case or reduced shipping when you order a half case. Shop full cases or half cases today!
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Grateful Gourmet: Inferno Habanero Pickles

    $7.99
    Grateful Gourmet: Inferno Habanero Pickles
    Taste the goodness in every bite with a Ghost Pepper kick!
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Grateful Gourmet: Pickled Asparagus Fire Stix

    $6.99
    Grateful Gourmet: Pickled Asparagus Fire Stix
    Taste the goodness in every bite with a jalapeno kick!
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Pat’s Gnaw Bone Sorghum Mill Blueberry Preserves

    $5.99
    Pat’s Gnaw Bone Sorghum Mill Blueberry Preserves
    Made the way grandma made hers, simple ingredients and great flavor from the fruit used.
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Harris Sugar Bush 1 Pound Maple Sugar

    $9.49
    Harris Sugar Bush 1 Pound Maple Sugar
    Granulated pure maple syrup. Made by boiling down pure maple syrup then drying and sifting to leave just sugar and trace minerals that give it it's natural sweetness and flavor.
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Sechler’s Sweet Gherkins

    $3.99
    Sechler’s Sweet Gherkins
    Great sweet gherkin pickles, appetizers or finger food trays need these
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Eisele’s Pure Honey 12oz Bear

    $7.99
    Eisele’s Pure Honey 12oz Bear
    All natural pure honey in a convenient squeezable 12oz bear
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Shoup’s BBQ Sauce

    $5.99
    Shoup’s BBQ Sauce
    A little Country in Every Bite.
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Broad Ripple Chip Co 1oz Original

    $0.99
    Broad Ripple Chip Co 1oz Original
    These chips contain no preservatives, no trans fats, no MSG, and are gluten free.
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Eisele’s Raw Honey 16oz Jar

    $9.99
    Eisele’s Raw Honey 16oz Jar
    Eisele's Raw honey is guaranteed to have never been heated to temperatures higher than those found naturally in the hive and has never been filtered or strained in any way. Assuring it contains all the elements in their purest form just as in the hive.
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Shipshewana Dark Chili Powder Copy

    $6.99
    Shipshewana Dark Chili Powder Copy
    We are pleased to offer authentic Shipshewana Spice Co. Happy Salt with shipping anywhere in the US! Use as you would salt. Shake on meats, salads, vegetables, bread and more. Enjoy free shipping when you order a full case or reduced shipping when you order a half case. Shop full cases or half cases today!
  • ADD TO CART..
    View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Coffee Time Gift Box

    $39.00
    Coffee Time Gift Box
    Coffee Time 1 Albanese Dark Choc. Espresso Beans, ½# 1 Albanese Milk Choc. Espresso Beans, ½# 1 Jameson Coffee, Jamaica Me Crazy, 12 oz 1 Hoosier Sugar Daddy German Vanilla Coffee syrup All products made locally in Indiana $ 39 […]
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    The Bourbon Collection Gift Box

    $62.50
    The Bourbon Collection Gift Box
    The Bourbon Collection 1 Bourbon Barrel Gift Pack assorted seasoning sampler 1 Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries, 13.5 oz. 1 Bourbon Barrel Dark Hot Chocolate with bourbon smoked sea salt 1 Bourbon Barrel Kentuckyaki 1 Master Hand Whiskey Bourbon Pickles   […]
  • View Cart
    Add to cart / Details

    Morning Toppings Gift Box

    $42.00
    Morning Toppings Gift Box
    Morning Toppings 1 Indiana Maple Syrup, 16 oz. 1 Eisele’s Pure Honey Bear, 12 oz 1 Bakehouse Gluten free Granola, 12 oz 1 Dillman Farms Strawberry Preserves, 16oz 1 Chandler’s Farm Apple Butter, 18 oz   All products made locally […]
Previous 1 2 3 Next
  • 302 E Washington St Greencastle,
    Indiana 46135
  • Monday - Friday: 10:00 - 6:00 |
    Saturday: 9:00 - 3:00
  • [email protected]
  • 765-653-1335
FIND US ON FACEBOOK
  • Our menu
  • Order a sandwich
  • Catering
  • Jam/Jelly
  • Sauce
  • Honey/Syrup
  • Seasoning
  • Pickles
  • Snack
  • Condiments
  • Misc
  • Gift Card
  • Beverage